YOWIE’s neighborhood guide to the best pizza in South Philly,from old-school favorites to new neighborhood finds. This list highlights South Philadelphia pizza places that showcase the flavor,character, and variety of the neighborhood.

If you want to explore more of the area, you can browse our Stories for additional guides, neighborhood picks, and nearby recommendations.

South Philly Pizza Cheat Sheet

If you’re deciding where to start, this cheat sheet gives a quick snapshot of the South Philly pizza places we’ve highlighted in this guide.

Pizzeria Stella: Wood-Fired Pizza and Pastas
420 S 2nd St
Dine In & Take Out

A family-friendly neighborhood spot with wood-fired pizza with gourmet toppings like black truffle. Stella also has an assortment of pastas, a great happy hour, and a quaint bar next door if you’re looking for a cocktail before or after dinner.

Pizzeria Stella is a longtime favorite for wood-fired pizza in South Philly, especially for diners looking for a relaxed neighborhood spot close to Old City and Queen Village.

Emmy Squared Pizza: Detroit-Style Pies and a Rooftop Bar

632 S 5th St
Dine In & Take Out

Small chain serving Detroit-style pizzas and an award-winning burger. Full service bar, local drafts & wine selection, and in the Summer has a lovely rooftop for dining with a view.

Emmy Squared is a go-to for Detroit-style pizza in South Philadelphia, known for its thick crust, crispy edges, and casual bar setting.

Square Pie: Thick-Crust Sicilian Favorites

801 Passyunk Ave
Dine In and BYOB & Take Out (Order Ahead)

A neighborhood staple for thick-crust, Sicilian-style pizza packed with so much flavor and a host of toppings. Order ahead to enjoy at home or in your hotel suite or dine in their cozy space. Be sure to grab a bottle of wine beforehand if dining in.

Square Pie is often mentioned among South Philly pizza places for its Sicilian-style pies and no-frills neighborhood feel.

CJ & D’s Trenton Tomato Pies at Cartesian Brewery: Old School Tomato Pies

1326 E Passyunk Ave
Wednesday, Friday, and Sundays
Dine In & Take Out (No Ordering Ahead)

Tucked away inside of Cartesian Brewery is CJ & D’s, a tiny, family-run spot serves just four Trenton-style pizzas: Cheese laid on top of the dough and then covered in sauce. The crust is thin and crunchy with just the right amount of char. Bring your patience and enjoy some brews while you wait, sometimes this one can take a while but it’s well worth it.

This spot stands out in South Philly for its Trenton-style tomato pies, a regional style that flips the usual cheese-and-sauce order. This is a good choice if you’re not in a rush and want to settle in with a beer while you wait.

San Lucas Pizza: Mexican Fusion Pizzas

2000 S Bouvier St
Take Out & Delivery Only

San Lucas is a two-decade-old pizzeria run by husband and wife Valentin Palillero and Eva Mendez. One of a few amazing Mexican fusion spots in the city, they are known for their vibrant ingredients and mixing of flavors.

San Lucas is a standout for Mexican fusion pizza in South Philadelphia, combining traditional pizza formats with bold, unexpected flavors.

Argicola: Farm-to-Table Pizza and Neighborhood Comfort

1180 S 10th St
Dine In & Takeout, No Delivery

In Latin, “Agricola” means “farmer” which embodies the restaurant’s farm to table spirit and their dedication to community and comfort. A vibrant homegrown spot that serves fresh ingredients. Neighbors have been known to see the owner walking his pet pig around the neighborhood.

Agricola fits well into the South Philly pizza scene for diners who care about seasonal ingredients and a community-driven menu.

La Rosa Pizza: A South Philly Potato Pie Favorite

2106 S Broad St
Take Out & Delivery Only

In a city full of red sauce pies La Rosa’s potato pie is one of our favorites. This no-frills spot is perfect to grab a slice or pie before heading down to the stadium for a game.

La Rosa is frequently mentioned when locals talk about classic South Philly pizza, especially for its well-loved potato pie.

Stina Pizzeria: Pizza with Mediterranean Roots

1705 Snyder Ave
Dine In & Take Out

The name is a little deceiving as their pizza is very good but their Mediterranean food is even more compelling. One of our favorite BYOB date night spots or perfect for a family dinner for your hard to please relatives.

Stina Pizzeria adds a Mediterranean influence to the South Philadelphia pizza landscape, making it a popular choice for something a little different.

Chiquita’s Pizzeria & Mexican Grill: Birria and Al Pastor Pizzas

746 Snyder Ave
Dine In & Take Out

Chiquita is a beloved Mexican fusion pizza spot. We love their specialty pizzas like the Al Pastor Pizza and Birria Pizza, which are layered with juicy meat and served with dipping sauces.

Chiquita’s is one of the more unique South Philly pizza places, known for blending Mexican flavors with traditional pizza formats.

Angelo’s Pizza: A South Philly Classic Worth the Wait

736 S. 9th Street
Take Out Only

We’re gonna warn you to be ready to wait and if you are, you’re gonna be rewarded with a delicious pizza (or cheesesteak) that you’ll be craving until your next visit. This place is cash only so plan ahead. The phone method is a good way to get ahead of the rush if you’re able to get someone on the line.

Angelo’s is often cited among the best pizza spots in South Philly, with long waits reflecting its reputation among locals. It’s a popular stop for lunch and early dinner, and showing up with time to spare makes the experience much easier.

Doughhead Pizza: Late-Night Slices and Specials

833 Wharton St
Take Out Only

A great drive by spot for when you’ve had a few drinks and don’t want to go home without an empty stomach. We’re partial to the pepperoni slice and keep an eye out for specials. Across from Pat’s and Geno’s if you’d like to go big and add a cheesesteak or cheese fries.

Doughhead is a familiar name in the South Philly pizza rotation, especially for quick slices after a night out. It’s an easy pick when you’re looking for something quick and satisfying on the way home.

Cacia’s Pizza: Bakery-Style Pizza and Italian Staples

1526 W Ritner St
Take Out Only

Family-run brick-oven bakery offering Italian staples like stromboli & pizza, plus cakes & pastries. Pizza is sometimes served cold, which isn’t for everyone.

Cacia’s represents an older-school side of South Philadelphia pizza, blending bakery traditions with pizza counter classics.

Stogie Joe’s: Pizza in a Neighborhood Tavern

1801 Passyunk Ave
Dine In & Take Out

A neighborhood joint with pizza, sandwiches & other pub grub items served in a bustling, laid-back tavern setting. If the weather is nice, enjoy your pizza outside.

Stogie Joe’s fits into the South Philly pizza scene as a relaxed tavern stop where pizza is part of a larger neighborhood menu.

Pizza Plus South: Detroit-Style Pizza for Game Night

1846 S 12th St
Take Out Only

Pizza Plus offers crispy Detroit-style pies that are perfect for game night in or sinking into your sofa after. Here, the deep dish pizzas are round and they load doughy and spongy slices with buffalo chicken, homemade pesto, or plenty of melty cheese for $25 and under.

Pizza Plus South is often mentioned for Detroit-style–inspired pizza in South Philly, especially for takeout and game nights.

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza: A Philly Square Pizza Institution

901 S 10th St
Dine In & Take Out

Beloved Italian Market institution serving square cheese-under-sauce pizzas & other Italian fare since 1959. Great for parties and ordering a bunch of people for family and friends.

Santucci’s is a cornerstone of South Philadelphia pizza history, known for its square, cheese-under-sauce style.

Planning a trip to Philadelphia? South Philly is known for our food scene, and pizza is a big part of it. Most of these spots are an easy walk or ride from from the YOWIE Hotel, and if you feel like keeping the neighborhood tour going, our South Street Sandwich Guide and Black-Owned Businesses guide offer a few more places worth the stop.